Follow Us

OPINION — In this uncertain economic landscape, we are all feeling a strain on our wallets. It is understandable, then, that the government is looking for ways to lower costs and ease financial stress for Americans. However, short-term cost-saving measures should never come at the expense of our long-term financial security, especially when it may place the protection of one of life’s most important investments – our homes – at risk.

In a misguided attempt to lower costs for some homebuyers, Fannie Mae is reportedly considering a new program that could prove to be harmful to homeowners in Wisconsin and across the country. The program would waive Fannie’s title insurance requirements on some loans it purchases, and the company would assume title risk and oversee future claims, becoming a de facto primary market insurer.

The title insurance industry is comprehensively regulated and actuarially reserved in Wisconsin, ensuring that homeowners and lenders alike are protected from risk. There are over 2,326 title professionals in Wisconsin like myself that work tirelessly to protect their clients from any and all threats to their property rights. That is why when I learned about this new program from Fannie Mae, one of the leading mortgage financing institutions in the country, I knew I could not remain silent.

Last month, I joined other title professionals from across the country to attend the American Land Title Association’s (ALTA’s) Advocacy Summit in Washington, D.C., to discuss my concerns with members of Congress. I had the opportunity to meet with Rep. Bryan Steil to discuss the risks and threats Wisconsin homebuyers, lenders, and the overall housing finance system could face from this program.

During my meetings with members of Congress, I also shared concerns about other attempts by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to replace title insurance with unregulated alternatives. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have begun to allow certain attorney opinion letters (AOLs) in lieu of title insurance in some circumstances on loans they purchase.

However, these alternatives only cover issues that can arise in a simple public records search, failing to protect against other defects not revealed in a simple search, unlike title insurance. Title policies also cover any legal costs associated with protecting property rights and from risks of fraud or forgery, which AOLs do not. Simply put, AOLs fail to provide the same ongoing protections as title insurance, potentially leaving both homeowners and lenders exposed to risk and large unforeseen costs.

I want to thank Rep. Steil for listening to these concerns and being a strong supporter of the title industry in Wisconsin. With his continued support, we will ensure that homeowners’ most important investments are protected.

Protecting and advocating for homeowners

My colleagues in the title industry and I will continue to advocate for Wisconsin homeowners, protecting them from risk and unforeseen financial costs. Title insurance provides essential protection, and we must remain vigilant to prevent any proposed shortcuts or unregulated alternatives that introduce greater risk.

Craig Haskins is a member of the Board of Governors of the American Land Title Association and COO of Knight Barry Title, Inc, whose 80+ locations in Wisconsin, Minnesota, Michigan, Florida, and Texas provide title insurance and title-related services to consumers, lenders, lawyers, developers, builders, and real estate professionals.

Letters to the Editor and Opinion pieces

The Racine County Eye and Kenosha Lens will publish Letters to the Editor and Opinion pieces as-is after fact-checking has occurred. If false information is submitted, attempts to contact the author for clarification will be made by Racine County Eye. Racine County Eye reserves the right to publish Letters to the Editor and Opinion pieces at its discretion.

If you are submitting an article, letter, or news story, please submit it in a Word document, and include a picture(s) for the article if possible. Please have your name, phone number, email address, and zip code at the top of the Letter. Materials must be submitted at least one week prior to the publication date. Exceptions will apply. Letters to the Editor and Opinion pieces may be sent to

The Racine County Eye, which includes the Kenosha Lens, is your source for local news that serves our diverse communities. Subscribe today to stay up-to-date with local news.

Follow us on Facebook: Racine County Eye or Kenosha Lens, and Twitter to make sure you get the latest news.

Racine County Eye and Kenosha Lens – Journalism that serves.